Areas Served
Your guide to Chautauqua Lake communities
Chautauqua Lake runs about seventeen miles through Chautauqua County, New York. On the lake itself, Bemus Point (NY 14712), Lakewood (NY 14750), Mayville (NY 14757), and Dewittville (NY 14728) anchor much of the shoreline market. Nearby Findley Lake (NY 14736) is a separate body of water with its own community character and pricing.
Chautauqua Lake shoreline
Villages and neighborhoods directly on Chautauqua Lake, NY.
Bemus Point
The quintessential Chautauqua Lake village with charming downtown, waterfront dining, and classic lakefront cottages.
- Village center walkability
- Year-round community
- Historic charm
Mayville
Gateway to Chautauqua Institution at the lake's northern tip, known for its marina and easy access to cultural events.
- Chautauqua Institution access
- Full-service marina
- Northern lake views
Dewittville
Quiet eastern shore community with a mix of year-round homes and seasonal retreats, perfect for those seeking tranquility.
- Peaceful atmosphere
- Affordable options
- Sunset Views
Lakewood
Incorporated village on Chautauqua Lake's western shore—easy reach of Jamestown, with neighborhood feel and straightforward lake access.
- Near Jamestown
- Western shore
- Village amenities
Nearby lakes & communities
Separate from the Chautauqua Lake shoreline—its own lake, market, and community character.
Which community fits you?
Illustrative ranges and drive times—always confirm pricing and timing with current listings and maps.
| Community | Typical pricing (illustrative) | Vibe | Approx. to Jamestown, NY | Waterfront |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bemus Point, NY 14712 | $350K–$800K+ (waterfront varies) | Walkable village; dining & social hub | ~15 min by car | Chautauqua Lake — docks, village shore |
| Mayville, NY 14757 | $300K–$700K typical waterfront | Northern basin; Chautauqua Institution access | ~20–25 min | Chautauqua Lake — marina, upper basin |
| Dewittville, NY 14728 | $250K–$550K waterfront often strong value | Quieter shore; sunset views | ~15–20 min | Chautauqua Lake — bays & residential shore |
| Lakewood, NY 14750 | $250K–$650K (waterfront varies) | Residential village feel; close to Jamestown | ~5–10 min | Chautauqua Lake — village shore & nearby docks |
| Findley Lake, NY 14736 | $175K–$400K waterfront (illustrative) | Smaller lake; calm, private feel | ~25–30 min (separate lake) | Findley Lake — smaller body of water |
Chautauqua Lake at a Glance
Chautauqua Lake lies in southwestern New York. Drive times vary with season and route; many out-of-town owners plan on roughly ninety minutes from Buffalo, about two hours from Pittsburgh to the lake area, and two and a half hours from Cleveland—making long weekends realistic from much of the Great Lakes region.
17
Miles long
2
Miles wide (max.)
~42
Miles of shoreline (approx.)
75–78 ft
Max depth (north basin)
Depth and shoreline figures are approximate; sources often cite shoreline length in the low 40s of miles and maximum depth around 75–78 feet in the northern basin.
Not sure which area is right for you?
Let's talk about your priorities—budget, lifestyle, proximity to amenities—and I'll help you narrow down the perfect fit.
Talk to Heidi